But you have until 6 p.m. today. The bosses response was: We dont care about your problems, go ahead and quit. The soldier is in the unit, hes not running away anywhere. Along with eight others, Dmitri told his commanders that he refused to rejoin the invasion. It's absurd. Why wasn't it done?". By The Associated Press August 11, 2022. The unit, stationed in Russias far east during peacetime, first entered Ukraine from Belarus when the war started at the end of February and saw bitter combat with Ukrainian forces. In phone conversations with Current Time, he said troops were not granted any leave for 4 1/2 months, even as the losses and casualties for the brigade mounted: Up to half of the brigades personnel -- around 1,000 -- have been either killed or wounded in action, he said. A junior sergeant said he was injured during one of the recent Ukrainian attacks on the Russian border territory where he was stationed. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Russian forces were driven out of much of the northeastern Kharkiv region in early September by a Ukrainian counter-offensive that allowed Kyiv to retake thousands of square kilometres of territory. TASS said the soldier expressed his dissatisfaction with the training of mobilised servicemen outside Moscow. We drove around it and on, firing as we went. Poland sent the German-made tanks to help Ukraine repel Russian troops and send a "clear and measurable signal of further support", said Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, who was visiting Kyiv . And that means he cant be prosecuted for desertion or going AWOL. The private then pushed the officer in the chest. We arent officially in a state of war, so they could not force me to go.. But then someone said they'd take my son to work in the storeroom. Separately, a military tribunal said it sentenced Kandarov to five years behind bars for evading military service during mobilisation for more than a month. Were bringing the voice of Ukraine to the world. The official warned that the next phase of the war was likely to be an "attritional conflict" which could last . Why Russian Soldiers Are Refusing To Fight In The War On Ukraine. Troops from the Russian so-called Cossack Detachment are refusing to take part in offensive operations due to Russian forces' heavy losses near Vuhledar in Donetsk Oblast. He gets it now. Honestly, we had to supply ourselves with food. What is being given to Ukraine by the UK? It doesn't make sense. Instead they were expected to operate without even basic equipment, such as night vision devices, he says. ET. Although Sergey does not want to return to the front line, he does want to complete his outstanding military service in Russia to avoid any unforeseen consequences. I'm shocked by our army. But even before that, there are many reports from our intelligence officers, who work quite successfully, about what is going at the enemy both in the rear and on the front line there are very frequent refusals to participate in hostilities., Read also: Russians pushing for breakthrough near Vuhledar, but unlikely to succeed, says UK intelligence. The man narrated the ordeal his son suffered to the BBC, saying that he had begged his son not to go. Many soldiers, therefore, have chosen to be fired or transferred rather than going into the meat grinder, he said. "Later I was told that the building they were in had been shelled and that all five men were missing. In conversations with Current Time via the Russian social media giant VK, several soldiers from the brigade disputed the circumstances behind their inclusion on the wall of shame. Source: General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine on Facebook, Quote from the General Staff: "Troops from the so-called volunteer Cossack Detachment, attached to the 155th Marine Brigade of the Russian Pacific Fleet, are refusing to continue to take part in offensive operations due to the failure of the offensive and significant personnel losses near Vuhledar.". Read about our approach to external linking. For all of RFE/RL's coverage of the war, click here. Nearly five months into the largest war in Europe since World War II, a growing number of Russian soldiers like Kaminsky are refusing to fight, demanding to return home, or outright not going to Ukraine in the first place. A Russian serviceman takes part in military exercises outside the city of Yuzhno-Sakhalinsk in the Russian Far East on September 4. In his unit of 50 people, 10 were killed and 10 others wounded. On 15 February, Ukraines Defence Intelligence reported that Russias losses were the largest since the beginning of the full-scale invasion. Unit commanders then staged an intervention. Sergey is just one of hundreds of Russian soldiers understood to have been seeking such advice. He says his convoy - travelling through northern Ukraine - broke up after just four days when a bridge they were about to cross exploded, killing comrades ahead of them. April 7, 2022. Ukrainian . President Vladimir Putin had on September 21 ordered a mobilisation of hundreds of thousands of Russians to fight in Ukraine, sparking protests and an exodus of eligible men from the country. Without a formal . Independent Russian media have also been reporting hundreds of cases of soldiers refusing repeat deployments to Ukraine since the beginning of April. "I think that [so many of] our guys died largely because of this. At another moment, he said, unit commanders ordered a squad of five soldiers to try to seize a nearby settlement defended by up to 200 Ukrainian soldiers. "In these months [of compulsory military service] that I have left, anything - including the worst - could happen. In January, Sergey was sent near the border with Ukraine for what he was told would be military drills. They didn't even [try to] dissuade us, because we weren't the first," Sergey told the BBC. VLADIMIR Putin's demoralised and disillusioned troops are fleeing the war in Ukraine and surrendering without a fight, reports claim. Were bringing the voice of Ukraine to the world. If a soldier acts according to such procedures, then he cannot be criminally prosecuted for this. We didnt have normal munitions, no flak jackets or helmets. They forgot their military oaths, the ceremonial promise, their vows of duty to their Fatherland, the board reads. Finance chiefs at a Group of 20 conference in India this weekend issued a joint statement condemning Moscow for its war in Ukraine, with only China and Russia declining to sign. The soldier's testimony said war-weary soldiers were urged by superiors to return to the fight. The troops are getting exhausted they wont be able to keep this up for a long period.. They made him lie on the ground and told him to count to ten. The soldier, not wanting to take part in a special military operation, did not report for duty in May 2022, said the press service on Thursday for courts in the region of Bashkortostan in the southern Urals. A similar account to Dmitris was given to the BBCs Russian service by Sergey Bokov, a 23-year-old soldier who at the end of April decided to leave the army after fighting in Ukraine. He shares that soldiers in Crimea refused to be . In a rare public spat involving the Kremlin, 25 National Guard 'refuseniks' defied their . According to the General Staff of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, the occupiers are not able to resolve problems with manning their units. CNN's Frederik Pleitgen reports on the conflictin Ukraine as Russian President Vladimir Putin touts success, yet some ofhis soldiers refuse to fight. R ussian troops have destroyed a concrete dam built in Ukraine's Kherson Region in 2014 to cut off water to Crimea, the RIA news agency quoted the governor of Russian-annexed Crimea Sergei . We were illegally jailed.. As casualties have mounted, so have Ukrainian officials' efforts to appeal directly to the Russian people, saying they are being lied to about a war Moscow still calls a "special operation . Born in Russia, he graduated from St. Petersburg State University and also received film and video production training at Bard College in New York. Russia has also turned to mercenaries to bolster its war efforts, deploying fighters from the shadowy Kremlin-linked Wagner group. There are no legal grounds to start a criminal case if a soldier refuses to fight while on Russian territory.. Troops from the Russian so-called Cossack Detachment are refusing to take part in offensive operations due to Russian forces heavy losses near Vuhledar in Donetsk Oblast. Russian . Ukraine's leader pledged Friday to push for victory in 2023 as he and other Ukrainians marked the somber anniversary of the Russian invasion that upended their lives and Europe's security. In Buryatia, where the 11th Brigade is based, dozens of personnel have sought legal assistance from local activists, seeking to break their contracts and get out of service in Ukraine, for various reasons. The URL has been copied to your clipboard. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty 2023 RFE/RL, Inc. All Rights Reserved. "They beat him and then they took him outside as if they were going to . DeSantis won't say he's running. We didn't leave anyone in the rear, so if someone decided to come in from behind and hit us there was no protection. 1 min read. He is now home in Russia, having taken legal advice to avoid being sent back to the front line. Some Russian troops are refusing to return to fight in Ukraine because of their experiences on the front line at the start of the invasion, according to Russian human rights lawyers and activists. 2d ago. Daughter of Putin ally dies when . According to the head of his military commandant's office, Kononov was found at his place of residence with a friend after a search. Russian servicemen near Kherson, Ukraine - 20 May 2022, By Olesya Gerasimenko and Kateryna Khinkulova, A convoy of Russian military vehicles heading towards the Donbas region - 23 February 2022, Local residents by a destroyed Russian tank in Sloboda, Chernihiv, Ukraine - 8 May 2022, Banner with the letters Z and V, in support of the Russian military, on a building in Moscow - 19 May 2022, Russian service personnel rehearse for the Victory Day Parade in Moscow - 7 May 2022, President Vladimir Putin visits soldiers wounded during the conflict in Ukraine - 25 May 2022, Pinned down by Russian fire in key front line village. More than 26,000 Russian military personnel have been killed in . It is unfair, I am fighting in this war just as the others in Ukraine, risking my life, the soldier said. He's changed completely. The latest as of 7.15 a.m. What's he waiting for? A Russian soldier's service card was stamped "traitor" for refusing . Almost immediately his unit found itself under attack. They were furious. Join half a million readers enjoying Newsweek's free newsletters. Initially he "believed it was right" despite his dad trying to convince him not to go to war, the BBC report said. Source: Latvia-based Russian media outlet Meduza; united press office of the courts of the Republic of Bashkortostan on Telegram Details: According to court materials, Corporal Marcel Kandarov has been charged with evading military service for more than one month . By Robert Coalson. He believed it was right. Conscripts could fill some of the gaps, but they will be poorly trained. Russian troops sabotaging their own equipment and refusing orders in Ukraine, UK spy chief says Published Thu, Mar 31 2022 7:30 AM EDT Updated Thu, Mar 31 2022 4:40 PM EDT Chloe Taylor @ChloeTaylor141 Russian troops also lost territory in the southern Kherson region as well as the Lyman transport hub in eastern Ukraine. Despite speculation beforehand, Putin did not formally declare war on Ukraine during his Victory Day speech on 9 May. Ukraine's Operational Command South reported in a . Sergey joined the army as a conscript - most Russian men between the ages of 18-27 must complete one year of compulsory military service. Rumours abound of some Russian soldiers defying orders and refusing to cross into Ukraine to fight. The young Russian was among those men who enlisted. "I'm morally exhausted. Homesick. Soldiers like Sergey - reluctant to return to the front line - are not unusual, according to Ruslan Leviev, the editor of Conflict Intelligence Team, a media project investigating the experiences of the Russian military in Ukraine through confidential interviews and open source material. Support us with a one-time donation, or become a Patron! "It's a way of making people go back into that bloodbath," says Elena Popova from Russia's Movement of Conscientious Objectors. The enemy has somewhat reduced its activity for the fourth day, he said. Russian authorities quietly stepped up their efforts to recruit new soldiers as it became clear that a quick victory in Ukraine was unattainable. Several lawyers and human rights activists the BBC spoke to said they had been regularly offering advice to men trying to avoid returning to Ukraine. Many of us simply did not want to go back, said Dmitri, a member of the unit who asked not to be identified with his real name. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Russian soldiers are increasingly dying from accidental friendly fire . Dmitri's refusal to fight in the war is the latest in a string of reports of Russian soldiers disobeying orders to join the fight. 'You're Nobody' Russia blaming Ukraine for killing of daughter of Putin ally, Daughter of Putin ally dies when car explodes, Russian media says, 'Russia is not Putin': 76-year-old Russian uses her art to speak out, Russian priest says he's helped 'thousands' of Ukrainian refugees get to Europe, Putin unveils imperialist mission: taking back land he says is Russia's, See rebranded McDonald's restaurants unveiled in Russia, CNN reporter was at Russia's Victory Day parade. He simply declares that he has anti-war convictions. Russian paratroopers. It wouldn't cost much to equip us. Feb. 27 2023, Published 8:05 a.m. That's what people who have come from there say.". For some Russians, refusing to return to the front line may be a moral stand. An anonymous specialist from a coalition of lawyers and experts from Russian human rights organizations told independent Russian news outlet MediaZona that Kononov's punishment in the form of a one-year restriction in military service does not imply early dismissal and is instead "something like corrective labor for military personnel.". AP. "Another reason is the foul way they're being treated. Artillery sentry duty? When the soldiers of an elite Russian army brigade were told in early April to prepare for a second deployment to Ukraine, fear broke out among the ranks. Jan 27, 2023. "It was blown up from a grenade launcher or something else. Russia has suffered a series of military setbacks in the Ukraine war that triggered criticism of the army's leadership. Back in his living room, Sergei tells me that what happened to Stas in Ukraine has brought them closer together. Frank Gardner looks at what lies ahead as winter arrives in Ukraine. A Russian official this week responded to the Biden administration's refusal to rule out sending depleted uranium anti-tank munitions to Ukraine by warning that deployment of such weaponswhich have been linked to birth defects, miscarriages, and cancerwould be regarded by Moscow as use of "dirty nuclear bombs." According to . The soldiers testimony said war-weary soldiers were urged by superiors to return to the fight. But there's a more common explanation. And this, according to a video on social media app Telegram, has . "There are held in pits, tortured and things like that. "We're on the same wavelength now," Sergei tells me. Critics have said many mobilised men hardly had any battlefield experience and have received little training before being sent to the front. "They beat him and then they took him outside as if they were going to shoot him. They made him lie on the ground and told him to count to ten. I want to return to my family and not in a casket.. Ilya Kononov, a contract soldier from the city of Pskov in western Russia, was charged with "unauthorized abandonment of the unit" in July, court records show. Hawara: 'What happened was horrific and barbaric', The people who want you to believe the Ukraine war is fake. "We went without helicopters - just in a column, as though we were heading to a parade.". A Russian court sentenced Marsel Kandarov to five years in prison for refusing to take part in the special military operation. There have been an estimated 140 soldiers put behind bars in eastern Ukraine, with some allegedly guarded by pro-Moscow mercenaries in a military base surrounded by land mines, the Guardian reported. Here's what he saw, CNN reporter returns to Russia for first time since January, Kremlin to showcase its military power in May 9th parade. By Timofei Rozhanskiy. Their identities have been protected by the BBC. Youre just a soldier for them; youre nobody.. Mr. Putin had resisted ordering a mobilization for months, but his decision underscored the Kremlin's struggles on the battlefield, where more than 80,000 Russian soldiers have been killed or . I told him that he was a zombie. But after a certain adaptation period, our men fight brilliantly.". The Institute for the Study of War said on 14 February that the deployment of conscripted servicemen by Russian troops is unlikely to create sufficient offensive potential for a large-scale and rapid mechanised offensive. While speaking, he blew cigarette smoke into an officers face, who responded by pushing him away. They just don't care. "Then they took him into a room and told him: 'You're coming with us, otherwise we'll kill you.' Human rights activist Sergei Krivenko says he is not aware of any prosecutions of those refusing to return to the front. Andrei, a Russian lieutenant, stopped fighting. There is absolutely no trust in the authorities and the higher command, from the very first word, Kaminsky, 20, told Current Time in a phone interview on July 17, recorded from an undisclosed location in the Luhansk region of eastern Ukraine. Kaminsky said discontent had been building in the unit for weeks, if not months. Some troops are refusing orders, walking away from military bases or crossing the border into Ukraine and switching sides, media reports show. More than 100 Russian national guardsmen have been fired for refusing to fight in Ukraine, court documents show, in what looks to be the clearest indication yet of dissent among some parts of . "Inclined toward treason, lies . "We rushed forward with short overnight stays, without trenches, without reconnaissance. Argument | Michael Walzer. According to Kaminsky, the pressure ended up working in part: As of July 16, 50 of the 78 soldiers who had demanded to return to their home base had relented. At some point, Kaminsky's unit was then transferred to Luhansk, in Ukraines Donbas region. Russia lacks sufficient ground units with contract soldiers for a sustainable rotation. And that, unfortunately, life would prove that.". Perhaps this is due to the weather conditions, which doesnt allow them to actively use military equipment now, the spokesperson said. "I can see that the war continues, it is not going away," he told the BBC. Now, at least four want their superiors punished for the seemingly illegal arrests, according to the newspaper. Stas, an army officer, had written a letter to the . Almost all his comrades were under the age of 25. Nearly all . Sergei (not his real name) says his son was beaten with a pistol for refusing to go back to the frontlines, There are reports of mobilised Russian troops locked in cellars and basements for refusing to fight in Ukraine, Record numbers of guide dog volunteers after BBC story. The beach, just north of Odessa in southern Ukraine, was defended with mines and anti-tank hedgehogs. The range of experience varies. Some Russian troops are refusing to return to fight in Ukraine because of their experiences on the front line at the start of the invasion, according to Russian human rights lawyers and activists. Some Russian troops are refusing to return to fight in Ukraine because of their experiences on the front line at the start of the invasion, according to Russian human rights lawyers and activists. We've changed them to protect their identities. "He said it was my choice. "They beat him and then they took him outside as if they were going to . In July, the father of a Russian soldier told The Insider that troops were being detained or moved to a detention center in the occupied Luhansk region if they attempted to leave their posts. Boris Johnson's cabinet received an update from a senior national security official on Tuesday morning. Many of the units that are supposed to train conscripts are fighting themselves, Lee said. The Russian authorities dismiss reports of disillusioned soldiers and detention centres as fake news. "They beat him and then they took him outside as if they were going to shoot him. Refusal then would mean much harsher penalties. A senior US defense official said Russian volunteers are refusing to go into . Kononov reportedly had taken part in President Vladimir Putin's so-called special military operation in the Eastern European nation but left his military unit without permission for more than 10 days. The Russian defense ministry didnt respond to the Guardians request for comment. - Ukraine's President . He told me his face was covered in blood. ", "My first thoughts were 'Is this really happening to me?'". 02:32. But, after a few months, he made the decision to sign a two-year professional contract which would also give him a salary. Journalists fight on their own frontline. Law enforcement located the man, Marsel Kandarov, in September, the statement added. They don't care about the life of a soldier; whats more important is his position and rank, Kaminsky said. An investigation by the BBCs Russian service showed that Russias defence ministry filled employment websites with vacancies, offering people with no combat experience opportunities to join the army on lucrative short-term contracts. We had no food, no water, he said. A Russian soldier who refused to continue fighting in Ukraine, he was beaten until his face was covered in blood, his father has claimed. Their official status is missing in action. It said that the troops lacked support, while personnel in advanced positions didn't have water. Missing In Action: A Russian Soldier's Mother Desperately Seeks Answers, Vox Pop: Muscovites On How Russia's Isolation Affects Daily Life. For four and a half months, Corporal Ilya Kaminsky and his fellow soldiers from the 11th Separate Air Assault Brigade have waged war as part of the grinding Russian military offensive that has slowly pushed Ukrainian troops back in eastern Ukraine. Pointing to Russias military laws, Benyash said it would be more difficult for soldiers to refuse to fight if Russia were to declare a full-scale war. That is not to say that prosecutions are not being attempted. But without conscript battalions, Russia could soon struggle to hold the territory it currently controls in Ukraine, especially as Ukraine receives better equipment from Nato, he said. He refused so they beat him over the head several times with a pistol. All Rights Reserved. Russian state media aired footage of blitzed buildings and abandoned streets in Bakhmut , the eastern city where Ukrainian forces have been . The Ukrainian military on Friday reported significant fighting near Ivankiv, about 40 miles north west of Kyiv, as Russian forces apparently tried to advance on the capital from the north. But his stand changed after the soldier found out he had been sent to fight with "no intelligence gathering, no preparation and no cover". The Insider. Hundreds of Russian soldiers have refused to fight or fled their posts since the war in Ukraine began, according to report published Wednesday by The Wall Street Journal. The commanders know only violence and intimidation. "It was a difficult decision for him to take. Ukrainian service members are seen at the site of fighting with a Russian raiding group in Kyiv on the morning of February 26, 2022, according to Ukrainian service personnel at the scene. Then I started getting messages from him asking what would happen if he refused to fight.". Ukrainians have been asked to avoid going near windows or on balconies and be . We were fed once a day at lunchtime. As they stopped for the evening in an abandoned farm, their commander said: "Well, as you will have worked out by now, this is not a joke. Of the 78 soldiers from Kaminskys unit who have disobeyed orders, some have been ordered held in a makeshift brig for days, he said. He told me his face was covered in blood," the father said while speaking to the outlet. Before joining Current Times Moscow bureau in 2019, Rozhanskiy worked for the independent Russian television channel TV Rain. I dont regret it one bit. "I don't want to go [back to Ukraine] to kill and be killed," says Sergey - not his real name - who spent five weeks fighting in Ukraine earlier this year. Another soldier from the 205th Brigade also said commanders gave no preparation to soldiers before the war, and when the units deployed, they were told they were going on exercises. Putin's army continues its full-scale aggression in Ukraine. Updated at 1:10 p.m. on April 14 to add that the soldier's lawyer has taken down the original photo of the service card. In another incident, Sergey says he had to overtake comrades trapped inside a burning vehicle in front of him. The men, who belonged to the key headquarters of the Pskov . Among them were 12 national guardsmen from Russias southern city of Krasnodar who were fired after refusing to go to Ukraine. Reports of Russian soldiers refusing to fight in Ukraine are also mounting. Some Russian troops are refusing to return to fight in Ukraine because of their experiences on the front line at the start of the invasion, according to Russian human rights lawyers and activists. Sergei and Stas are not the real names of this father and son. It's not a war of liberation'," the man told the BBC. Stas was sent back to Russia. Read also: UK intelligence estimates Russian losses near Vuhledar. 2023 Cable News Network. I thought a long time about it and came to the decision. Russians might be in favour of the conflict, but they dont actually want to fight, he said, adding that a general mobilisation would entail colossal losses of untrained soldiers. But they eventually calmed down because there wasnt much they could do, he said. I told him: 'Better to take it. Read about our approach to external linking. But, he had been sufficiently worried about his unit's reaction to his refusal that he decided to seek legal advice. Like us on Facebook to see similar stories . Support Ukrainska Pravda or become our patron! If we had moved gradually, if we had checked the roads for mines many losses could have been avoided.". Some Russian soldiers and even whole units are "refusing to fight" in Ukraine, top UK security officials reported today. Belarus, a close ally of Russia, has supported its eastern neighbour in the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine.Before the start of the offensive, Belarus allowed the Russian Armed Forces to perform weeks-long military drills on its territory; however, the Russian troops did not exit the country after they were supposed to finish.