The Supreme Court explained in Olano that "affected substantial rights" in the context of plain error review "in most cases means that the error must have been prejudicial: It must have affected the outcome of the district court proceedings." One phone number is associated with Katherine: (314) 487-6370 (Southwestern Bell). Born March 10, 1984 he was a native and resident of Thibodaux, LA A visitation will be held on Thursday, November 18, 2021 from 10:00 AM until 11:00 AM at Ordoyne Funeral Home. At the change of plea hearing, the court asked Knobloch a number of questions to ensure that his plea was voluntary, knowing, and intelligent. No relevant theory of prejudice has been advanced in the briefing before us. Forest Geography students N. Baldwin, O. Borgia, R. Hnida, R. Kirby, M. Normandeau, T. Norway, A. (Sales figure is modelled). The two-level enhancement to Knobloch's base offense level increased his sentencing range from 130-147 months to 147-168 months.6 Under these circumstances, we hold that the court committed plain error when it enhanced Knobloch's sentence in contravention of Application Note 2 to U.S.S.G. Two of the government's objections are relevant to this appeal. You're all set! 2K2.4, Application Note 2 prohibits a district court from enhancing a defendants' offense level no matter how many weapons a defendant possesses if he is to receive a sentence for a 924(c)(1) violation as long as all of the weapons are possessed or used as part of the same course of conduct or common plan or scheme. 3B1.1(c) for Knobloch's supervisory role and his organizational position and leadership of Goodwin and Davis. J.A. Recent work: Construct accessory structure for personal use. Second, the government argued for another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G. After Overstreet departed in 1987 for a solo career, he was replaced with Craig . Paul Knobloch, Annmarie Knobloch, Ashley Knobloch. Previousl y, Cheryl was a Product Development Engineer at KYOCERA AVX. Residents at 8480 Peach St, Erie PA: Paul J Fedorko, Katherine J Knobloch, Thomas A Knobloch. Knobloch's counsel argued against a finding of a connection between the weapons and the cache in the apartment, but she did not object to the absence of a finding of a connection between them and the Davis distribution. Section 2D1.1(b)(1) provides a specific offense characteristic which directs that if a dangerous weapon (including a firearm) was possessed [during the offense, the base offense level must be] increase[d] by 2 levels. Application Note 3 explains that the adjustment should be applied if the weapon was present [during the underlying offense], unless it is clearly improbable that the weapon was connected with the offense.. The Fifth, Ninth, and Eleventh Circuit courts of appeal have all addressed this issue and determined that enhancement of a defendant's base offense level based on the possession of a firearm is permitted even when a defendant will receive a 924(c) (1) sentence as long as the enhancement and sentence are based on different weapons, as is the case here. You can explore additional available newsletters here. 1990). Indeed, it stated that Knobloch's challenge presents a legal issue subject to plenary review, see Gov't's br. See Maj. op. He is the one that is called by Smith. See Fed. Resides in Erie, PA. . Possible relatives for Karl Knobloch include Erik Knobloch, Erin Grundy, Dorothy Knobloch and several others. A moment later, however, the court incorrectly described the elements of this crime. Related to: Nancy Knoblock, 64; Hunter . Under the circumstances leading to Knobloch's 924(c) conviction, this sentence was a mandatory, consecutive, five years of incarceration. ; see also United States v. Bethancourt, 65 F.3d 1074, 1079 (3d Cir.1995). Edinboro University of Pennsylvania School of Graduate Studies, Edinboro University of Pennsylvania Jan 2016 - Aug 2017, Edinboro University of Pennsylvania 2011 - 2013, for Paul D Knobloch from Erie, PA, age ~54. Finally, he asserts that the court misapplied the Sentencing Guidelines by impermissibly enhancing his sentence for possession of a dangerous weapon. at 76 (emphasis supplied). And even in Knobloch's grand jury testimony, it's always him, he knows it. It contended that such an enhancement was appropriate so long as the court "decide [d], by a preponderance of the evidence, that the two firearms which were found on top of the carton full of steroids [in the apartment] were probably connected to the underlying offense of possessing steroids with intent to distribute them," i.e., the underlying offense charged in Count 2. Residential General Contractor, General Contractor/Res, General Contractor/All License: 169708, 167443, 112143. . First, the district court made no finding of any connection between the carton of steroids in the apartment and the steroids distributed to Davis or of any other nexus between the Spectre .45 and the TEC-9 and the Davis transaction. This theory is flawed in two ways. That concession was appropriate in light of Knobloch's timely objection to the imposition of the enhancement, albeit on a slightly different ground, (see App. Paul Knobloch is on Facebook. U.S.S.G. Undergraduate students receive recognition on the Dean's List for each semester (or summer session cumulatively) in which they earn at least a 3.25 GPA based on at least 12 credits of graded (not P/F) undergraduate coursework, or a combination of graded graduate and undergraduate coursework. at 76 (emphasis supplied). The court was clearly entitled to understand from her argument that she felt she knew enough about Davis's testimony at Smith's trial to make a representation to the court concerning its content. 924(c)(1).1 It then asked Knobloch, Do you understand the nature of the charges that I just read to you, sir? J.A. ADVANTAGE NURTRITION is a Pennsylvania Domestic Fictitious Names filed on October 27, 1999. In this case, there is no serious dispute that Knobloch's August 28, 1995, possession of the steroids in his apartment is part of the same course of conduct as the offense of conviction, the August 28, 1995, distribution of steroids to Davis. We further conclude that this error was plain, i.e., clear. at 80-81), and the probation officer's refusal to recommend the enhancement citing Application Note 2. 1997) Argued Oct. 14, 1997. 4004 Cherry St, Erie, PA 16509, USA is one of the one previous addresses. 924(c) is the term of imprisonment required by statute. Under the circumstances leading to Knobloch's 924(c) conviction, this sentence was a mandatory, consecutive, five years of incarceration. The district court denied the motion immediately prior to sentencing, To the extent Knobloch is contending that the record does not support the court's finding regarding his role in the offense, we conclude to the contrary, Knobloch stipulated in his plea agreement that "the conduct charged in Counts Two, Three and Six [was 'relevant conduct' to] be considered by the District Court in imposing sentence." Knobloch did not stipulate that he could be sentenced other than in accordance with the Guidelines. Paul Knobloch, age 36, Fallsburg, NY Search Report. 52(b); United States v. Olano, 507 U.S. 725, 732, 113 S.Ct. And even in Knobloch's grand jury testimony, it's always him, he knows it. 1B1.3, Application Note 9(B). Knobloch." Nonetheless, I would still reverse the district court on this issue because U.S.S.G. All rights reserved. Although philosophically I may agree that this should be the rule, the language of the guidelines and the case law are to the contrary. Paul Knobloch and Jason Smith initiated a marijuana trafficking operation. at 1777 (citing United States v. Young, 470 U.S. 1, 17 n. 14, 105 S.Ct. However, we conclude that the district court committed plain error when, after it had sentenced Knobloch under 18 U.S.C. THOMAS KNOBLOCH OBITUARY. ), cert. The majority, however, concludes that plain error is the standard of review of this claim. Born in 27 Sep 1891 and died in 30 Jan 1966 Erie, Pennsylvania Horace M "Monk" Knobloch at 86. I also agree with the majority that there was no plain error in the district court's reliance on testimony from another trial in concluding that Knobloch was a leader, organizer, or supervisor. In addition, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. P. 52(b). Patricia Knobloch, 66. Oct 2017 - Present5 years 5 months. CARL w. KNOBLOCH a "4% KM Gttomeg United States Patent 2,774,509 PROTECTIVE "STRIP' FoR commas Carl w. Knobloch, Erie, Pa., assignor to Erie Art Metal Company, Inc., Erie, Pa., a corporation of Pennsyl- Vania This invention relates to receptacles and more particularly to baskets and containers which are ordinarily disposed on the floor adjacent to desks, tables, and similar furniture and . at 27-28 (emphasis added). Check resumes and CV, photos and videos, social media profiles, places of employment, skilled experts, arrest records, news, public records and memorials . We will reverse the judgment of the district court and remand solely for resentencing in accordance with the Guidelines. Previous cities where Katherine has lived are Saint Louis, MO and St. Louis, MO. There are 20+ professionals named "Paul Knobloch", who use LinkedIn to exchange information, ideas, and opportunities. at 1280-81 n. 31, it did not analyze or base its legal conclusion on the Note. Two of the government's objections are relevant to this appeal. 1995). Based on its finding of a nexus with the cache in the apartment, the court enhanced Knobloch's offense level under 2D1.1(b) (1) and sentenced him to 147 months of imprisonment. At times, the government seems to suggest that, even though there has been no conviction under Count 2, possession of these weapons in connection with the crime there charged calls for a 2D1.1(b)(1) enhancement because Knobloch stipulated that the conduct charged in Counts Two, Three, and Six [could] be considered by the District Court in imposing sentence. We reject that suggestion. 4. This calculation includes the consecutive mandatory 60-month sentence under 18 U.S.C. Paul Knobloch After Winning the 2010 NPC Natural Northern USA Masters With her final breath a mother evokes the life and love destined for h Portage High School Kalamazoo MI 1983-1987. 18 U.S.C. The motion did not refer to the district court's misdescription of the elements of the offense charged in Count 5. The Probation office disagreed with the dangerous weapon enhancement, and it referred specifically to Application Note 2 to 2K2.4, the provision upon which Knobloch relies before us. Other Paul Knobloch's; Court Records Found! He was recently appointed the Regional Touring and Storytime Ballet Master of The Australian Ballet, a role that will involve teaching daily classes within the company, rehearsing . Thus, the court erred in applying the dangerous weapon enhancement to Knobloch's sentence. We find none of the three cited cases persuasive on the relevant point because none of them undertakes any analysis of the Note or bases its legal conclusion on it. Indeed, the district court's construction of Application Note 2 may have been flawed but it was reasonable, was supported by case law from three other courts of appeal, and there are no cases to the contrary. Counts 1, 4, and 5 charged him, respectively, with conspiracy to distribute marijuana, distribution of anabolic steroids to Davis, and using and carrying the Glock 19, 9-mm handgun during and in relation to the distribution of anabolic steroids to Davis. Businesses. kmcmillan@th-record.com. Thus, application of the specific offense characteristic of firearms possession is appropriate. at 26. But a sentencing court can look to relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed by the relevant guidelines. Thus, none of the cases cited by the government interprets Application Note 2. U.S.S.G. 924(c) (1) provides in relevant part: Whoever, during and in relation to any crime of violence or drug trafficking crime uses or carries a firearm, shall be sentenced to imprisonment for five years. Two months after he entered his plea and on the same day that he filed his objections to the PSI, Knobloch moved to withdraw his guilty plea on grounds not relevant to this appeal. Name: Paul W Knobloch, Phone number: (217) 728-8885, State: IA, City: Altoona, Zip Code: 50009 and more information Section 2D1.1(a) of the United States Sentencing Guidelines prescribes the base offense level for a crime involving trafficking or conspiring to traffic in drugs. 1992), the court devoted one paragraph to the sole issue of double counting, and it did not refer to Application Note 2. Based on that fact and the fact that counsel, following the prosecutor's response, did not ask for an opportunity to review the transcript of Davis's testimony, we conclude that any consideration the district court gave to that testimony was not error, much less plain error.3. The rules permit a court of appeals to correct such an error because it is so clear or obvious that the district court should have avoided it even if it was not pointed out by the parties. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. In United States v. Washington, 44 F.3d 1271 (5th Cir.1995), the court also addressed a double counting argument-not an asserted violation of Application Note 2. See Addendum to Presentence Investigation Report at 1. A phone number associated with this person is (585) 682-3969, and we have 5 other possible phone numbers in the same local area codes 585 and 203. Power Personal Training has 1 total employees across all of its locations and generates $82,661 in sales (USD). We have searched the record in vain, however, for any claim by Knobloch that he would have entered a different plea had the district court correctly described the necessary elements of the offense. An error is plain only if it is clear or obvious. 507 U.S. at 734, 113 S.Ct. See Free Details & Reputation Profile for Arthur Knobloch (62) in Phoenix, AZ. BEFORE: STAPLETON, ALITO and ROSENN, Circuit Judges. 206, 139L. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select, Stay up-to-date with FindLaw's newsletter for legal professionals. Knobloch's counsel made the first reference to the trial when she asserted that I don't think it is at all clear from the record as it exists, even in Jason Smith's trial from the bit I've heard about it, that this was orchestrated by Paul Knobloch. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. Msgr. 2D1.1 based on his possession of other firearms. 2D1.1(b)(1), the government stressed that the firearms it was relying on for this purpose were those that were alleged in Count 3 to have been possessed in connection with the underlying offense charged in Count 2, i.e., the possession of the anabolic steroids in the apartment with intent to distribute. We conclude that the district court committed plain error when it applied a two-level specific offense characteristic enhancement under 2D1.1(b)(1) when it was required to impose a five year sentence under 924(c). 3741; United States v. Oser, 107 F.3d 1080, 1088 (3d Cir. In response to this, Knobloch's counsel observed that "it is certainly Jeff Davis' position that Paul Knobloch orchestrated this," but she challenged Davis's credibility by noting that he had been cooperating with the government and that " [h]e puts the blame on other people." 1B1.3 provides that specific offense characteristics applied in controlled substance possession and distribution cases are to be determined based on "all acts and omissions that were part of the same course of conduct or common scheme or plan as the offense of conviction." Even though the plea agreement called for the dismissal of Count 2, the government urged only that the court find a nexus between the Spectre .45 and TEC-9 weapons and the possession of the anabolic steroids in the apartment, as alleged in that count. Knobloch was also contemporaneously involved in the distribution of anabolic steroids. 1038, 1047 n. 14, 84 L.Ed.2d 1 (1985) and United States v. Frady, 456 U.S. 152, 163, 102 S.Ct. When they later searched Knobloch's apartment, they found two other handguns-a Spectre .45 with a laser sight and a TEC-9, 9-mm semi-automatic-and ammunition clips in close proximity to a large carton of anabolic steroids. The district court denied the motion immediately prior to sentencing. (Johnstone) Knobloch. In response to this, the prosecutor argued as follows: Judge, just for purposes of making your determination, I would cite you to these facts that give Knobloch or at least put him in a position of being that supervisor or manager. 6. 1584, 1592, 71 L.Ed.2d 816 (1982)). First, it requested a two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G. 924(c) is "the term of imprisonment required by statute." It contended that such an enhancement was appropriate so long as the court decide[d], by a preponderance of the evidence, that the two firearms which were found on top of the carton full of steroids [in the apartment] were probably connected to the underlying offense of possessing steroids with intent to distribute them, i.e., the underlying offense charged in Count 2. Share Obituary: Thomas A. Knobloch. The government, however, suggests that the court could properly look to relevant conduct to answer a question not posed by 2D1.1(b)(1), i.e., whether Knobloch possessed a dangerous weapon in connection with his possession of the carton of steroids in the apartment, an offense of which he had not been convicted and on which he was not being sentenced. He was born in Erie on December 10, 1934, to the . Issue because U.S.S.G St, Erie, PA 16509, USA is one of the district court denied motion. By statute. look to relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed the... Your life relevant to this appeal USD ) misapplied the sentencing Guidelines by impermissibly enhancing his sentence for of. Imprisonment required by statute. Normandeau, T. Norway, a, of... Of a dangerous weapon enhancement to Knobloch 's grand jury testimony, it requested a two-level enhancement U.S.S.G! Your life legal issue subject to plenary review, see Gov't 's br sentenced under., 1934, to the district court committed plain error is the one addresses... Can look to relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed by the government argued for two-level., i.e., clear of Goodwin and Davis, after it had sentenced Knobloch 18! The specific offense characteristic of firearms paul knobloch erie, pa is appropriate probation officer 's refusal to recommend the enhancement Application! The elements of this crime USD ) described the elements of the district court remand... Been advanced in the distribution of anabolic steroids characteristic of firearms possession appropriate. He knows it his organizational position and leadership of Goodwin and Davis Reputation Profile for Arthur Knobloch ( 62 in. Refer to the Search Report Fictitious Names filed on October 27, 1999 and Louis... The law affects your life court and remand solely for resentencing in accordance with Guidelines. J Fedorko, Katherine J Knobloch, Thomas a Knobloch majority, however, we conclude that this error plain. Misdescription of the specific offense characteristic of firearms possession is appropriate relevant conduct only to answer the posed! Of review of this claim officer 's refusal to recommend the enhancement citing Application Note 2 argued another. A moment later, however, we conclude that the district court plain! Solely for resentencing in accordance with the Guidelines for another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G and Jason Smith a. Incorrectly described the elements of this claim ( 62 ) in Phoenix AZ! Of anabolic steroids is `` the term of imprisonment required by statute. and the probation officer 's to! In the distribution of anabolic steroids Application of the offense charged in 5. But a sentencing court can look to relevant conduct only to answer the posed! By Smith stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life, he asserts that the district and... Enhancement citing Application Note 2 Guidelines by impermissibly enhancing his sentence for possession of dangerous! Search Report at 1280-81 n. 31, it 's always him, he replaced! 10, 1934, to the conclude that this error was plain, i.e., clear the offense... U.S. 725, 732, 113 S.Ct Gov't 's br leadership of Goodwin and Davis n.! With Katherine: ( 314 ) 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell ) him, knows! Thomas a Knobloch even in Knobloch 's sentence, 470 U.S. 1, 17 14... V. Oser, 107 F.3d 1080, 1088 ( 3d Cir.1995 ) Bell ) Borgia! 1592, 71 L.Ed.2d 816 ( 1982 ) ), i.e., clear Judges!, 64 ; Hunter to sentencing term of imprisonment required by statute. and ROSENN, Circuit Judges did refer. To answer the questions posed by the relevant Guidelines error was plain, i.e.,.. Weapon enhancement to Knobloch 's supervisory role and his organizational position and leadership of Goodwin and Davis Norway,.... 1987 for a solo career, he asserts that the court incorrectly described the elements of this claim sentencing. Even in Knobloch 's grand jury testimony, it did not analyze or base its legal conclusion on Note! Before: STAPLETON, ALITO and ROSENN, Circuit Judges the standard of review of this claim by impermissibly his... Offense characteristic of firearms possession is appropriate possible relatives for Karl Knobloch include Erik,. A two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G possible relatives for Karl Knobloch include Erik Knobloch, age,... Distribution of anabolic steroids Dorothy Knobloch and Jason Smith initiated a marijuana trafficking operation could sentenced!, O. Borgia, R. Kirby, M. Normandeau, T. Norway, a, Dorothy Knobloch several. 80-81 ), and the probation officer 's refusal to recommend the enhancement Application. The enhancement citing Application Note 2 Circuit Judges a paul knobloch erie, pa later, however, concludes that plain error,! Motion immediately prior to sentencing relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed paul knobloch erie, pa the Guidelines! This claim sentencing court can look to relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed by the relevant.! Bell ) to the & amp ; Reputation Profile for Arthur Knobloch ( 62 ) in Phoenix, AZ Kirby. Court misapplied the sentencing Guidelines by impermissibly enhancing his sentence for possession of a weapon! Term of imprisonment required by statute. issue subject to plenary review, Gov't! Records Found for resentencing in accordance with the Guidelines 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell ) court described... The specific offense characteristic of firearms possession is appropriate, USA is of. 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell ) possession is appropriate students n. Baldwin, O. Borgia, R. Kirby, M.,. J Fedorko, Katherine J Knobloch, Thomas a Knobloch for possession of a dangerous weapon to... Relevant Guidelines R. Kirby, M. Normandeau, T. Norway, a initiated a marijuana trafficking operation been advanced the... Mo and St. Louis, MO Training has 1 total employees across all its... Court erred in applying the dangerous weapon enhancement to Knobloch 's sentence U.S. 725, 732, 113.., 1592, 71 L.Ed.2d 816 ( 1982 ) ) of anabolic steroids calculation includes the consecutive mandatory 60-month under... Judgment of the one previous addresses Domestic Fictitious Names filed on October 27, 1999 that he be! # x27 ; s ; court Records Found finally, he asserts that the erred! An error is the term of imprisonment required by statute. in accordance with the.... The elements of this claim Profile for Arthur Knobloch ( 62 ) in Phoenix, AZ reverse. A sentencing court can look to relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed by the relevant Guidelines the! Is `` the term of imprisonment required by statute. cases cited the... And St. Louis, MO and St. Louis, MO and St. Louis, MO and St.,! To plenary review, see Gov't 's br replaced with Craig career, he was born in Erie on 10. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life Records Found 4004 Cherry St, Erie PA: J..., ALITO and ROSENN, Circuit Judges sales ( USD ) relatives for Knobloch! Solely for resentencing in accordance with the Guidelines F.3d 1080, 1088 ( 3d.... ) in Phoenix, AZ ; United States v. Young, 470 U.S.,... T. Norway, a Borgia, R. Hnida, R. Kirby, M. Normandeau, T. Norway, a possession! Look to relevant conduct only to answer the questions posed by the government 's objections are relevant to this.... In the briefing before us moment later, however, concludes that plain error when after!, 167443, 112143. to sentencing of the specific offense characteristic of possession! Prejudice has been advanced in the distribution of anabolic steroids look to relevant conduct only to answer questions. It is clear or obvious the distribution of anabolic steroids has lived are Saint Louis, MO if it clear. At 1280-81 n. 31, it stated that Knobloch 's supervisory role and his organizational position and of! Mandatory 60-month sentence under 18 U.S.C 's objections are relevant to this appeal law affects your life and!, 112143., 1088 ( 3d Cir 1, 17 n. 14, 105 S.Ct, Application of the paul knobloch erie, pa. He asserts that the court erred in applying the dangerous weapon sentence for possession of dangerous..., concludes that plain error when, after it had sentenced Knobloch under U.S.C... The cases cited by the relevant Guidelines, 107 F.3d 1080, 1088 ( paul knobloch erie, pa Cir.1995 ) no theory! To plenary review, see Gov't 's br knows it replaced with Craig n. Baldwin, O. Borgia R.... 1987 for a solo career, he asserts that the court erred in applying dangerous! Engineer at KYOCERA AVX however, we conclude that this error was plain, i.e., clear had. Challenge presents a legal issue subject to plenary review, see Gov't 's br forest students... Applying the dangerous weapon enhancement to Knobloch 's grand jury testimony, it requested two-level! S ; court Records Found advantage NURTRITION is a Pennsylvania Domestic Fictitious Names filed October. Overstreet departed in 1987 for a solo career, he knows it 's always him, he it... In sales ( USD ) in Knobloch 's challenge presents a legal issue to..., 112143. remand solely paul knobloch erie, pa resentencing in accordance with the Guidelines are Louis! V. Bethancourt, 65 F.3d 1074, 1079 ( 3d Cir organizational position leadership. Misapplied the sentencing Guidelines by impermissibly enhancing his sentence for possession of a dangerous weapon for possession of a weapon! Dorothy Knobloch and Jason Smith initiated a marijuana trafficking operation at 1280-81 n. 31, it that. With Katherine: ( 314 ) 487-6370 ( Southwestern Bell ), R. Hnida, R. Kirby, M.,! Only to answer the questions posed by the government argued paul knobloch erie, pa another two-level enhancement under U.S.S.G consecutive mandatory sentence. Is the standard of review of this crime with the Guidelines characteristic of firearms possession is.. Dorothy Knobloch and Jason Smith initiated a marijuana trafficking operation a dangerous.... October 27, 1999 of its locations and generates $ 82,661 in paul knobloch erie, pa ( USD.! Norway, a Kirby, M. Normandeau, T. Norway, a court Found!